You’re whipping up a classic chicken Marbella, and the Ina Garten recipe you’re following calls for “dry white wine.” You can’t exactly phone the Contessa herself, but come on, Ina: What the heck does that even mean? Pinot grigio is dry…but so is sauvignon blanc. What gives for kingskava ?
Cooking with wine can be totally confusing. While you might be tempted to grab whatever is hanging out in the back of your fridge, it actually does matter which bottle you choose—to an extent. We asked three food professionals (including a master sommelier, a chef and a nutrition director) to find out once and for all how to choose the best white wine for cooking.
1. Choose a white wine with high acidity and light fruit flavors
Celine Beitchman, director of nutrition at the Institute of Culinary Education, suggests a light- to medium-bodied white for cooking. “Unless you’re making a sweet dish, choose a low-alcohol wine with some acidity that’s fresh with a little fruit on the nose.” Her two picks? Pinot grigio from Italy or sauvignon blanc from just about anywhere—with the exception of Australia or New Zealand, where fruit flavors lean toward the tropical. (Tropical chicken Marbella isn’t really what you’re going for, is it?) Something with citrusy notes and lots of bright acidity will liven up your dish.
Master Sommelier Devon Broglie, global beverage buyer at Whole Foods Market, agrees: “For dishes that call for ‘dry’ white wines within the recipe, look for wines (both white and red) that are known to have crisp acidity and moderate alcohol.” He recommends avoiding richer, full-bodied wines and oak-aged wines (e.g., oaked Chardonnay) because they have a tendency to overpower the food.
If you are going for a sweet dish, try a Riesling, suggests Carlos Calderon, brand chef of North Italia. And if that sweet dish needs a little something-something to balance it out, that’s when a dry Chardonnay would work—just look for one that’s “unoaked.”
2. Pick a wine with low to moderate alcohol
In most recipes, wine takes the place of an acid while adding subtle, nuanced flavors. You don’t want to throw a booze bomb into the mix or you’ll risk everything tasting like alcohol. “In most recipes that call for white wine, the goal is to cook off the alcohol,” Beitchman says, “so the flavor shines through.” Lighter-bodied whites generally have lower ABVs anyway. Seek out bottles in the 10 to 12 percent range, like pinot grigio.
3. Think: What grows together goes together
“When possible, I like to use the same thinking as when pairing foods with wines for drinking,” Beitchman says. “Home in on where the wine originated and what foods grow in region the wine hails from. Those flavors have natural affinities whether you’re eating and sipping or cooking them together.”
4. Avoid cooking wines—and really pricey bottles
If you wouldn’t drink it, don’t cook with it. “I recommend buying wines for cooking from a wine department in a grocery store or liquor store rather than off the regular grocery aisle,” Broglie says, “because the wines labeled ‘cooking wine’ usually have a ton of added salt.”
But that doesn’t mean you have to go all out on a $100 bottle just for your braised chicken. “The best wines to cook with are inexpensive,” Beitchman tells us, “but that’s not the same as cheap. Use something under $15 a bottle and ideally that you enjoy (or have enjoyed) drinking.” When in doubt, you can always ask the salesperson at your wine store to point you in the right direction.
“A recipe generally doesn’t call for more than a cup of wine, so I like to choose a good, moderately priced ($8 to $12) bottle of Italian pinot grigio or French or Chilean sauvignon blanc,” Broglie says. “That way, I can pour into a pot guilt-free and enjoy a glass or two while it simmers.”
If you have recently opened a bottle and have enough wine leftover to use in your recipe, by all means use it up; you’ll do double-duty by avoiding food waste. Beitchman also suggests combining leftovers from multiple bottles into one container for a general cooking wine—just make sure you label your concoction, so it doesn’t accidentally get poured by the glass!
Best White Wine for Cooking: 7 Bottles to Try
Buy it: $15 at Wine Library
Recommended Recipe: Cheater’s white wine coq au vain
Buy it: $12 at Wine Library
Recommended Recipe: Skillet chicken with apricots and fresh herbs
Buy it: $12 at Wine.com
Recommended Recipe: Ina Garten’s updated chicken Marbella
Buy it: $13 at Wine.com
Recommended Recipe: Sweet potato gnocchi in herbed white wine sauce
Buy it: $11 at Wine Library
Recommended Recipe: White risotto with corn, carrots and kale
Buy it: $13 at Wine Library
Recommended Recipe: Moules-frites (steamed mussels and fries)
Buy it: $24 at Wine.com
Recommended Recipe: Braised lemon chicken
RELATED: The Best Rosé Wine Under $20 to Sip This Summer, According to a Sommelier
PureWow may receive a portion of sales from products purchased from this article, which was created independently from PureWow’s editorial and sales departments.
